Picture Perfect: Before and After Photos-- Can You Trust Them?
To get a good idea of the surgery results, you should be looking at photos taken from more than one angle - so you can see all sides of the patient
If you've ever removed red eye from a digital photo, you know how much fun imaging software can be. With practice - and the help of a program such as Photoshop - you can even take your ex-boyfriend right out of the picture! Which has to make one wonder - are before-and-after photos the real deal?
Toronto plastic surgeon Dr. Mitchell Brown explains that it's not difficult to manipulate pictures digitally. While conducting research on the variables affecting nipple symmetry, he said he took one photo of a breast. "Using my imaging software, I was able to come up with almost forty realistic variations of the same breast by changing the size, shape, colour and placement."
There are several ways to protect the integrity of an image - by embedding a digital watermark, storing the image with WORM (Write Once Read Many) software, or incorporating an icon attesting its authenticity. Even with these deterrents, it's easy to alter a photo. For this reason, Brown says such organizations as the American Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery expect their members to adhere to a code of ethics: in other words, they shouldn't alter before-and-after photos to make results look better than they really are.
Dr. Michael Kreidstein, another Toronto-area plastic surgeon, says that The College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario doesn't support the use of before-and-after photos in advertising. "Photos are so powerful, we respond without thinking," he says. "Ideally, an ad should carry the disclaimer: 'This is an example of the surgeon's work, but it is not necessarily representative.'"
Often, a problem with photos is the surgeon's failure to disclose all the procedures a patient has had. "A practitioner might be illustrating how well a particular cream works, but deliberately leave out the fact the patient has also had a facelift," says Kreidstein. "Marks, wrinkles and lines and blemishes can easily be removed by imaging software too."
Lighting can affect pictures, too. "In a before photo of acne, pockmarks can be accentuated by lighting the patient from above," he says. "Then, by changing the light source to the front in the after photo, results will look more impressive because the shadows are less defined."
Brown says that the angle from which a patient is photographed can also make a procedure appear to be more successful than it really is. "Photographing the body at a 45-degree angle provides the most flattering perspective, but not necessarily the most accurate one." To get a good idea of the surgery results, you should be looking at photos taken from more than one angle - so you can see all sides of the patient.
Clothing plays another major factor. "The way clothing is arranged can also give the illusion of a better result," adds Brown. "With an abdominoplasty or liposuction, undergarments should be in the same position, not pulled up or down to exaggerate the result."
Of course, what doctor wouldn't want to choose the most dramatic images to portray his work? According to Kreidstein, photo selection bias is more common than photo manipulation. "Seeing a few pictures of really good results can be comforting to patients, but they must consider whether or not they're only looking at the best results." Brown agrees. "It's only human nature to want to show your best work, but what I try and do is to show the typical results that I get nine times out of 10."
Both surgeons stress that patients shouldn't be too worried about altered photos. "I am convinced most of my colleagues are ethical," states Brown. "But it is a potential issue, and patients can educate themselves by knowing just what to look for."
What to look for in before-and-after photos:
- Size. Both pictures should be taken from the same distance and cropped identically.
- Angle. Pictures taken at a 45-degree angle may be more flattering.
- Lighting. Shadows and "soft focus" lighting are common clues to deceptive photos.
- Clothing. With body surgery, the patient should be wearing the same clothing, styled in the same way. Posture should be identical - slumping exaggerates any body problems.
- Makeup. If a patient is wearing makeup in the after photo, they should be wearing makeup in the before picture, too.
Finally, ask to see many, many photos. The more you see, the better idea you'll have of average results, and what's too good to be true.
Published: 01/07/2005, Last Updated: 08/08/2005
By Susan Williamson
This article was also featured in Elevate Magazine. Interested in subscribing?
The cosmetic enhancement magazine dedicated
to men and women in pursuit of optimum beauty.
Get 40% off the cover price for only $15 a year (5 issues) plus get this year's Cosmetic Enhancement Guide. Click here to subscribe.
Visit the
Elevate Magazine special section for more articles.
Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants) Surgery Information Guide
-
Basics of Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants)
"I've heard about the surgery and I'm looking to learn a bit more about things like cost, whether it's right for me, and what options I have."
-
- Surgery: Deciding About Breast Implants for Reconstruction
When thinking about surgery for breast cancer you will have many important decisions to make. One decision is whether to have surgery for breast reconstruction at all.
- Breast Augmentation (Enhancement) Basics
Breast implants have, for years, been a popular procedure for women seeking cosmetic enhancement. Learn about your options and typical costs.
- See Your Procedure in 3D

- Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants) IQ Quizes
-
Details of Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants)
"I already know some basic things about the surgery and I'm ready to research some of the details and maybe ask some questions."
- Plastic Surgery Breast Implants
New York plastic surgeon, Dr. Mrodcai Blau, describes the art and technique behind breast augmentation.
- Questions Frequently Asked by Women with Implants
If you are serious about breast enlarement this article will dive into many of the details of the surgery and post operative care.
- Doctor Discourse: Should Implants be Placed Above or Below the...
Are you considering getting breast implants? If you are, then one of the biggest decisions you and your surgeon are going to have to make is whether to have the implants placed above the muscle (subglandular) or below the muscle (submuscular). Not sure what the differences are or which one is right for you? This article will help you understand the benefits of each and when they should be used so that you will be able to ask the right questions during consultation to help you get the results you want.
- Cohesive Gel: Can Silicone Implants Be Safe?
Cohesive gel implants are the newset technology in the world of breast augmentation, but, for now, are only available through FDA trials. Read what one plastic surgeon participating in the trials has to say about them and how his patients respond.
- System Lowers Breast Augmentation Re-operation Rate By 17 Percent;...
Plastic surgeons take new approach to patients with existing silicone implants and decrease the need for re-operation.
- Safe Plastic Surgery
Plastic surgeon, Dr. S. Sean Younai describes the safe way to choose plastic surgery, and discusses additional considerations that could affect your procedure.
- Patient Perspective: How Preparation Can Make Surgery More Comfortable...
When two or more cosmetic procedures are combined into one surgical visit, the prospect of going under anesthesia for an extended period of time can be both scary and risky for the patient. For Dallas native Brenda Dickson, being informed and asking the right questions helped combat pre-operative fear.
- Post-Pregnancy Repair
Read the benefits and see the results of cosmetic surgery after pregnancy, and help determine if it is right for you.
- How the Face and Body Age... and how we can combat the telltale...
Age, smoking, diet, sun exposure, and other factors all contribute to changes in physical appearance. Learn what can be done to reverse these changes.
- Teens Should Be 18 for Cosmetic Breast Augmentation, ASPS Recommends...
Policy developed by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) requires that women seeking breast augmentation for cosmetic pruposes be at least 18 years of age.
- 10 Things You Need for Recovery After Plastic Surgery
Your procedure may leave you with scars, pain and stress during the recovery stages, and planning ahead with the right tools and supplies can make recovery much easier. Here are the top ten things you need.
- Breast Enlargement Without Surgery – Is it Possible?
While millions of women go under the knife for breast augmentation procedures each year, many are exploring alternatives to surgery. What are the options?
- Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants) Before & After Photos
-
Ready for Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants)
"I've pretty much finished by research on the surgery and I think I'm ready to find and meet with a doctor to get started."
-
- Seven Signs You’re Ready for Plastic Surgery
If you’ve decided to jump into a plastic surgery to fix a figure flaw, you’ll be joining millions of Americans going under the knife for the latest procedure. But are you really ready?
- Find Plastic Surgeons In Other Cities
- Patient Financing
Think you'll need help paying for your surgery? Almost anyone is a candidate for easy financing of up to 100% of the surgery costs.
-
After Breast Augmentation (Breast Implants)
-
- Recovering from Breast Implants
When Susan Campbell realized her silicon implants were making her sick, she began a journey of self discovery through rest, faith and natural remedies. Some healing strategies that helped...
- An In-depth Look at Breast Implant Complications and How to...
Complications from a breast augmentation can be painful, expensive, and an unwanted hassle for months or even years to come. In this article you will get and in-depth description of some of the major complications, learn some steps you can take to avoid them, and get educated on what to look for and what you can do if they do occur.
- Breast Augmentation Complications: The Double Bubble
When implants are placed behind the muscle in women with sagging breasts a unique complication commonly referred to as double bubble can occur. Learn how it can be avoided and how it can be corrected post-operatively.
- When Implants Bottom Out: How it Happens, How it's Fixed
When an implant begins to migrate downward from its original placement, it results in a lower fold at the bottom of the breast, making the nipple appear too high. Learn contributing causal factors and how the complication can be corrected.
- Understanding Symmastia: How it Forms and How it's Treated
Symmastia occurs when implants placed bellow the muscle dislodge and touch in the middle of the chest. Learn more about this complication and how it is corrected.
- Understanding Capsular Contracture: Its Risks and Treatments
Capsular contracture is one of the most common complications associated with breast augmentations. Learn how to help prevent its occurance and how it can be treated.
- Hate How You Look? You May Be More Likely To Commit Suicide
Many women are getting breast implants to boost their self esteem, but research shows that some may be doing it to mask an even bigger psychological problem that could lead to suicide.
- Recommend Your Doctor